- 5 stars: 160 (72%)
- 4 stars: 11 (5%)
- 3 stars: 12 (5%)
- 2 stars: 21 (9%)
- 1 star: 18 (8%)
so im just gonna start this by saying trixie is an amazing makeup artist but this eyeliner is not it. i bought it bc i do goth makeup and just eyeliner here and there. i have been doing my eyeliner for almost 8 years atp. i read reviews and have watched her videos on this product and i thought it would come close to replacing my tried and true nyx cosmetics eyeliner. when opened it up to use it, im not even gonna lie, this is 100% one of the blackest eyeliners ive ever used. the actual formula of the eyeliner is outstanding. its quick drying and DOES NOT MOVE. the only downside is it being a felt tip. the actual tip on the end was pretty much dry and was actually pulling up my makeup as i was using it on the eyes. idk if i got a faulty one bc i see people in the reviews using it and it looking great. i think she needs to work on this product again bc there should not be this many inconsistencies with the product. like i know i don’t make makeup or anything but i think she needs to switch to a brush tip liner bc those are the easiest to rehydrate and mold to the shape you want imo. all and all shes a great makeup artist and im not bashing i just hope she can fix this issue and make the best product possible:)) (the pic is just to show the type of makeup i usually do and possibly why it wouldn’t work for me)
I love Trixie makeup because it works for a makeup girly. I can put this eyeliner over my eyeshadow without a problem. It dries super quick, never makes a mess and always looks great. I just repurchased but my last one lasted me months. The tip is perfect, precise and easy for someone who doesn’t have an amazingly steady eyeliner hand
I fly around all day and most of my liquid pen liners end up leaking and a lot of them can’t keep up with my long days and ever changing climate, but I love this pen liner. It has not leaked on me after dozens of flights, It has an extra sharp point and it stays beautiful all damn day
This eyeliner has major staying power, I was really sweating and wiping my face. The product didn't come off. Also I love how easy it is to do cat eyes (at least that is what I call it:) I would definitely recommend this product to friends and family. Thanks Trixie! Another great product for my makeup bag💋
so here’s the thing. it works SO well. but it really doesn’t last long it started drying out after like 3 uses. if you’re a daily eyeliner wearer you’ll run through it really fast. i bought 2 bc i wanted to have a backup and i’m glad i did bc a week into having it it started to dry up mid-use, so i’ve had both pens open and i rotate through them both to do my eyes. it’s super cunt don’t get me wrong but they either need to include more product in the component or edit the formula so it doesn’t dry out as fast. but the felt tip is the best i’ve ever used it’s SO good and precise. also it’s very waterproof–this was me on a humid 85° day after performing and wearing for 12 hours. so in that sense it’s basically unbeatable. mwah
From an aged, elder Millennial/baby Gen-X/Xennial this is THE best pen liner I've used. Been lining my eyes with liquid liner, lo these past 28 years, and have tried then all, brush tip, felt tip, plastic tip. This is the BEST I've used, and the formula, OBVIOUSLY, smudge proof, tear proof, sweat proof. As a single mom on the cusp of perimenopause who still likes to be cute, I cannot recommend this enough!
I decided to give my go-to Smashbox liquid liner a bit of a break to give Trixie's liner a try and I am not disappointed! The felt tip for Trixie's is a bit thinner and a touch longer so I did have worries that maybe it would have more bend and give and thus not maintain a fluid line as smoothly but those fears quickly dissipated! The tip maintains even pressure and application easily, the color is rich and the tip doesn't drag through the product so you're not having to touch up areas already covered. The liner holds up well with zero transfer and I live in a super humid area. Even with the lightest of touches, the liner draws on smoothly and sets in a timely fashion (yay for not taking forever to dry). Super happy with this purchase, the formula is a dream and the applicator is perfect!
Everything is perfect, from the buttery smooth application, to the bold darkness, to the sharp precision! Not to mention that the price is less than I'd pay at the drug store. Zero complaints!
I wore this eyeliner and played softball and it didn’t budge. No other eyeliner I’ve used has done this except for kvd tattoo liner. Major slay.
Trixie girl I’m sorry but this pen liner is a miss! On my very first use it was streaky and poor pigment payoff - pic was after several swipes. Maybe my eyelids are oily or something but the NYX is superior.
So easy to use and so black. Sometimes the liner will not glide so well, but putting the cap on seems to help bring the flow back. We will see how long the product lasts, but happy so far!
I enjoy the tip. I feel like I'm getting way better precision. Plus it's black and not grey like other liners. I'm really enjoying it!
The tip applicator is stiff enough for a detailed look but will budge for movement very easy application good for beginners and pros
I never got a good use out of it. It arrived dry. I use this style of eyeliner all the time and have never received on that was completely dry. I really hoped to like it.
it’s not super black and by the next day it’s completely worn off
Best pen liner!
SOOO precise, one of the best liners on the market
My mom loves it!
its very waterproof/ smudge proof however i found it a bit flakey and after only 1 use it has already dried out :( it was pretty disappointing!
This baby dries down FAST, which is something I have been looking for! Works beautifully, and if you make a mistake you don’t have to worry about it smudging everywhere when trying to clean up ledges. The black is VERY black. Not gray or charcoal, but a true black. Perfect for detailing, special designs, or just your daily wing. Love love love.
+ good coverage
+ nice application
+ very precious
- does start to crack with wear time
- gets easy to rub with wear time
-> pretty good eyeliner compared to some of the stuff out there but not as what I was looking/hoping for
Trixie Cosmetics is always excellent!!
That it’s a vegan make up company is essential for me—i only use vegan products.
There are many amazing vegan make up brands. I’ve become addicted to creating a cat’s eye with liquid liner. Trixie’s Hotline Pen Liner is definitely the best one. Best control while drawing on my cat’s eye and best vivid results. I have a tendency to overdraw my cat’s eye—ends up kinds like Amy Winehouse…..which is very fine if that’s what you’re going for, but i want it more subtie. That subtie cat’s eye line on the base of my upper lid is best with this liner.
Just got this last week. This is my second time using it and the tip is already dried out no matter how much I shake it. I can't do my wing :(
It worked well for a couple of weeks but dried out very quickly and doesn't work well over eyeshadows.
Hi there! I'm sorry to hear this happened! If you haven't already, please reach out to our customer support team so we can help you with this!